Home   |   About Us   |   Contact Us   |   Brackets   |   Pick ’em   |   Meet the Writers   |   Archives   |   Subscribe to RSS Feed   |   Facebook   |   Twitter   |   TCF Store
The Cleveland Fan
BoardsPodcastsCrosswordsBars & RestaurantsBrownsCavsIndiansBuckeyesVikingsGeneralMovies & TVBoxing & MMA
Today's Slate
Visit us on Facebook
Visit us on Twitter
Today in Cleveland Sports History
Latest Poll
Quote of the Day

The Cleveland Fan Live
Best Cleveland Sports Blogs
Best Cleveland Websites
Our Partners
It must be the offseason - at least in Berea - since Josh Cribbs and the Browns are engaged in what has become their annual contract standoff. And whi ...
Dave Kolonich continues his position by position look at the 2009 Browns, this morning focusing on the wide receiver position ... clearly not one of t ...
Let's put aside for the moment Cleveland Browns' president Mike Holgrem's decision to retain head coach Eric Mangini or even Holmgren's pursuit of his ...
It would be so easy for Josh Cribbs to look like the good guy in his contract dispute with the Browns. He has been told to play the role of the good ...
Lost in the pre-December abyss of the 2009 season is the job that Mangini and special teams coach Brad Seely performed with largely a group of roster ...
As Eric Mangini is surely relieved to be celebrating his one-year anniversary as coach of the Browns, it's apparant that the dawning of a new era is a ...
If this were Hollywood, it could easily pass as a remake for The Great Escape. To the surprise of some, new Cleveland Browns president Mike Holmgren ...
He's coming back. Eric Mangini has defied the odds, risen from the depths of an almost unprecedented coaching abyss, and will be back next season to ...
To quote Judge Smails of "Caddyshack" fame ... "Well ... we're waiting." Yes, the Cleveland Browns nation sits and waits for new team President Mike ...
What a difference a month makes. A month ago the Browns were in the middle of a seven-game losing streak with no end in sight, Mike Holmgren appeared ...

Preview: Bengals at Browns
October 4, 2009 · By Jesse Lamovsky

Time: 1:00 pm, Sunday, October 4, 2009 

Location: Cleveland Browns Stadium  

Network, Announcers- CBS: Ian Eagle and Rich Gannon 

Line: Bengals by five-and-a-half. 

Team W/L Records: Cleveland is 0-3; Cincinnati is 2-1 

Coaches: Eric Mangini 23-28 overall, 0-3 with the Browns; Marvin Lewis is 48-50-1 in his seventh season with the Bengals. 

Last Week for the Browns: Hit rock-bottom (at least for the time being) in a 34-3 loss to the Ravens in Baltimore. At halftime Eric Mangini replaced Brady Quinn with Derek Anderson, who vindicated his coach's decision with three second-half interceptions and a quarterback rating of 30. 

Last Season for the Bengals: Climbed back from a 20-9 third-quarter deficit to beat Pittsburgh 23-20, scoring the winning touchdown with 14 seconds to play. It was Cincinnati's first home victory over the Steelers since 2001. 

All-Time Series: Bengals lead, 36-35 

Last Meeting- December 21, 2008: Ken Dorsey and Bruce Gradkowski combined to go 12-of-22 for 72 yards and four interceptions as the Browns stretched their string of scoreless quarters to twenty in a 14-0 loss to the Bengals at Cleveland Browns Stadium. Cincinnati defensive back Leon Hall- who picked off three passes during the game- opened the scoring with a 50-yard interception return for a touchdown in the second period, pretty much icing things right there. Although the Bengals (3-11-1) weren't exactly potent, gaining 246 yards and scoring only seven points on offense, they didn't have to be against Cleveland's inept "attack" which gained 182 yards, turned it over four times and committed nine penalties.  

Out or Questionable for Cincinnati: T Andre Smith (foot) is out; CB David Jones (foot), CB Jonathan Joseph (foot), DT Domata Peko (neck), DT Tank Johnson (foot) and S Roy Williams (forearm) are questionable. 

Out or Questionable for Cleveland: K Phil Dawson (right calf), RB Jamal Lewis (hamstring) and G Floyd Womack (ankle) are doubtful; RB James Davis (shoulder), DE Kenyon Coleman (ankle), G Rex Hadnot (knee), G Eric Steinbach (knee) and DE Corey Williams (knee) are questionable.  

What to watch for the Bengals: Watch for the Bengals to do whatever they want, offensively, defensively, and otherwise. Cincinnati has played good football all year- they should be 3-0 and would be if not for the fluke play that got them beaten by Denver- and there's no reason to believe they won't continue to play good football on Sunday.


What to watch for the Browns: I'm not going to get into game plans, strategies or scenarios for Sunday. I'm way past that at this point. I'm just going to say this: 

Eric Mangini has to go. Preferably now. If not now, very soon.  

This guy has been a complete and utter disaster almost from the minute he squeezed his doughy body through the door at the Berea complex. He botched the draft, turning a premium pick into a center who can't execute a shotgun snap, a special-teams linebacker, a backup defensive end, a third-string quarterback, and a starting safety that happens to suck eggs and is a convicted sex offender.  

One of his two second-round picks, Brian Robiskie, can't even make the active list for a team with arguably the worst receiver corps in football.  

None of his hand-picked ex-Jets toadies have amounted to a hill of beans and his offensive line imports, particularly John St. Clair, have been little more than expensive turnstiles.  

Reportedly, agents are telling their free-agent clients to steer clear of Cleveland as long as this radioactive idiot is in charge.  

His team has flat-out quit on him in each of the first three games. Personally, I've never seen a coach lose a team as Mangini has lost this one. Of course, when you're fining players four figures for neglecting to put a three-dollar bottle of water on a hotel bill, you're not exactly going to win friends. 

The final straw for me was his handling of the quarterback situation, culminating in his benching of Brady Quinn for Derek Anderson at halftime of last week's loss in Baltimore. Now, I'm not in the bag for Brady Quinn, and as a matter of fact, he has been absolutely awful to start this season. On a pure football level, I had no problem with the change.  

Here's my problem: 

Eric Mangini had eight months to get the quarterback situation straightened out. He had two clear-cut options: use the fifth overall pick on a quarterback- namely, Mark Sanchez- or get rid of either Brady or Derek and anoint the leftover as his clear-cut starter, no ifs, ands or buts about it. He had every opportunity to bring clarity to the position- something the Browns, tormented by quarterback controversies over the years, sorely needed. 

Instead, what does he do? He trades the pick which could have put Mark Sanchez in a Browns uniform. He keeps both Brady and Derek and spends the entire preseason on a competition which settles absolutely nothing. (And save me the cries of, "But it isn't Mangini's fault! NO ONE STEPPED UP AND TOOK THE JOB!" In how many of these stupid competitions did anyone "step up and take the job?" Did Kelly Holcomb "take the job" in 2003? Did Charlie Frye "take the job" in 2007? When you have two mediocrities battling for a spot, guess what? Neither is going to distinguish himself. Duh!)  

Then, two weeks after finally naming a starter, Mangini benches him. For a guy who threw three interceptions in one half, along with a quarterback rating of 30.9 

He couldn't have botched this situation more if he'd tried. 

Absolutely nothing good has come out of Eric Mangini's tenure in Cleveland. And yeah, I know it's early and no, I don't care. I have no reason to believe the situation is going to improve one iota as long as this guy is around. I don't want to "give him another season." I don't want to "let him get his system and his people in place." I want him gone.  

Good Past Win over the Bengals- September 15, 1991: Matt Stover drilled his fourth field goal of the day, this one from 45 yards with four seconds left, to topple the Bengals at the Stadium, 14-13. Cleveland won despite not scoring a touchdown, getting all of their points from Stover's field goals and rookie defensive tackle James Jones's end-zone tackle of Bengals running back James Brooks. Brooks, a Cleveland killer from way back, had a tough day: not only did he give up a safety; he was also hit so hard by Browns rookie Eric Turner at one point that his facemask bent.   

Bad Past Loss to the Bengals- December 3, 1989: Already struggling with a loss and a tie in their previous two games, the Browns looked downright horrible against the Bengals, losing 21-0 at the Stadium. It was the franchise's first shutout loss at home since 1977. Boomer Esiason threw two touchdown passes, both in the third period, as Cincinnati broke the game open after halftime. Bernie Kosar had a bad day, completing 15-of-30 passes for just 130 yards and getting benched for backup Mike Pagel at the beginning of the fourth quarter.  

Next Week for Both Teams: The Bengals are at Baltimore; the Browns are at Buffalo. 

Trivia: The Bengals have won three of their last four against the Browns at CBS, including two shutouts (30-0 in 2006; 14-0 in 2008.)

All Rights Reserved 2010, The Cleveland Fan   |   Photos courtesy of Getty Images and Associated Press   |   Affordable web design by Ohio Connect
Home   |   Contact   |   The Boards   |   Brackets   |   Pick 'em   |   Browns   |   Cavs   |   Indians   |   Buckeyes   |   General   |   Movies/TV   |   Boxing/MMA   |   Archives