Meet The Writers
Five Questions For The Tribe
Five Questions For The Tribe
Spring training is on the doorstep. No, really, it is. Just don't turn on the weather forecast or look outside, and you'll realize it's OK to mouth the six-letter S-word. It appears the Indians, with the fortune of good health, should be able to once again field one of the most complete teams in baseball, a team that is superlative at nothing but competent at everything. As has been the case the past few years, the overall success of the 2007 Indians will hinge on some questions that need satisfactory answers. Papa Cass asks them.
Spring training is on the doorstep. No, really, it is. Just don't turn on the weather forecast or look outside, and you'll realize it's OK to mouth the six-letter S-word.
Pitchers and catchers report today to what will be the Indians' last spring training in Florida. The team will re-locate their February and March home back to Arizona next year, ending a 14-year run in Winter Haven.
This week is the beginning of what could be a make-or-break year for the Tribe.
In the second halves of 2004 and '05, this team proved they can mount a playoff run. Last year, hindered by a clunker of a bullpen, bad defense and inconsistent starting rotation, the Tribe managed to field one of the best offenses in baseball, outscoring their opponents by 88 runs, yet ended up in fourth place of the powerful AL Central with a 78-84 record.
began, GM Mark Shapiro has added another promising young player to the team in Josh
and has fortified the outfield and bullpen with solid, if unspectacular, veterans.
It appears the Indians, with the fortune of good health, should be able to once again field one of the most complete teams in baseball, a team that is superlative at nothing but competent at everything.
As has been the case the past few years, the overall success of the 2007 Indians will hinge on some questions that need satisfactory answers. Below are five of them:
1. Is Eric Wedge the right manager?
The longer Wedge stays as the manager, the less impressive he seems. His teams always find a way to bookend the season on bad notes.
Sluggish Aprils and late-season collapses have become yearly events under Wedge. One year, a lack of hitting is to blame. The next, it's a bad bullpen. Shapiro is to blame for some of that -- in the case of 2006, most of that -- but it's hard to ignore the fact that the common denominator through all of it is Wedge.
Some of his players don't appear to like his leadership style, which seems to bounce back and forth between ineffectual and controlling. It was a major factor in why the Indians underachieved to the extent they did last year.
Wedge and Shapiro have been scolded numerous times for giving the appearance that they are blindly loyal to each other. But that might be starting to change from the front office's standpoint. For the first time since becoming manager in 2003, Wedge has some real pressure on him to perform.
If this team continues to underachieve, Buck
is waiting in the wings. Make no mistake:
, a special assistant to Shapiro, is not a ceremonial hand-shaker and storyteller like Mike
was during his brief return to Cleveland in 2004.
is on this staff to make Wedge produce results. If Wedge doesn't,
will be chomping at the bit to replace him.
2. Will a closer emerge?
One of the reasons Shapiro went all-out in unsuccessful attempts to land B.J. Ryan and Trevor Hoffman a year ago was because he knew how weak the free agent class for relievers would be this winter.
Alas, Shapiro was outbid for Ryan and couldn't break Hoffman's long-standing ties to San Diego. So he was forced to belly up to the craps table and do some gambling this winter.
The Indians' free agent reliever class of Joe
, Roberto Hernandez and Aaron
are loose puzzle pieces right now.
is the career closer who has been sidetracked by injuries the past few years. In a best-case, scenario, he would take the closer's role and hold it all season, allowing everyone else to find their places in setup and middle relief.
In that sense,
is arguably the most important acquisition the Indians made this
will never again be the pitcher he was in anchoring the Red Sox's 2004 championship bullpen, he can still close games effectively when healthy. If he is not healthy, the same cascading effect that clobbered the 2004 and '06 bullpens will begin again.
will be forced into the closer's role, depleting the setup corps and forcing other pitchers to pick up the slack.
But at least we know that
can close games, which is a good insurance policy to have. Now if Wedge can just break himself of the habit of riding one or two relievers for huge chunks of the season.
was very nearly the total package. He hit for power, setting a single-season record for homers by an Indians shortstop. He hit for average, he showed good plate discipline and, after a shaky April, was competent defensively. His first full season in the majors earned him a five-year contract extension.
Then 2006 arrived and it all came crashing down: Brutal defense, backsliding offense and an attitude that screamed "I don't have to prove myself anymore."
was becoming the bane of Wedge's
. He went so far as to openly rip
in the media on several
. If you know the company line-embracing Wedge we all do, you know that's way out of character for him.
This year, few players are at a bigger crossroads than
. He is right back where he was at the start of '05, needing to prove himself.
As of right now, the Indians have no real fallback if
stumbles. The backup shortstop is Hector Luna and prospect
Cabrera is not ready for prime time. So, much like last year, the Indians have a lot riding on
. Hopefully he comes to spring training ready to play, otherwise the Indians are going to be scrambling for a new shortstop.
4. Is Ryan
the real deal?
took the Indians and their fans by storm in the second half of last year. After Ben
and Eduardo Perez were both pawned off in
took the first baseman's job and ran with it.
He drove in 45 runs in 50 games and quickly became every Tribe fans' favorite underdog. And his reward for that is ... to likely start the season on the bench.
Few moves this
have generated more controversy than the move the Indians haven't officially made yet. As of now, the plan is to platoon
with Casey Blake at first. Blake will get the lion's share of at-bats at first base, starting there against right-handed pitchers. Against lefties, Blake will move to right field and
will start at first.
Most fans can't believe the potentially-potent bat of
will be relegated to part-time duty in favor of giving Blake -- long accused of being a managerial lap dog -- a
has more control that we might realize.
has to do is continue to hit the snot out of the ball. If he does that, even the most ardent Blake supporter will concede that
needs to be in the
All he has to do is prove himself and keep doing it. What a novel concept, eh,
5. Is Andy
the real deal?
He had better be, because if
can't stay in the lineup, it's going to mess up a lot of other things for this team.
The Indians committed 100 percent to
as their third baseman of the future when they dealt Kevin
to the Padres for
. You'd like to think that was based more on what
has accomplished than what the Indians gave up (and blew up) to get him.
has shown Cleveland fans that he could be a Gold Glover at third. He should also hit for some pretty decent power for a corner infielder. But his ability to get hits is going to determine whether he can become a rock at the hot corner. To that end, there is some work to be done.
hit .226 for the Indians last year, and is a career .204 hitter in parts of two seasons with the Braves and Indians. It's a small sample, too small to really get an accurate gauge. But let's just hope it's growing pains and not an accurate depiction of the type of major-league hitter
is Brooks Robinson in the field and Russell
at the plate, it's not going to add up to long-term success.
Feb 14, 2007 7:00 PM
Tweets by @TheClevelandFan
NBA Announces 2013-2014 Schedule
Browns Ink Sharknado
Sharknado A No-Show For Rookie Camp
Trent Richardson Out Until Training Camp
Browns Sign Brandon Jackson
Carrasco Suspended Eight Games
Browns Add to Wide Receiver Depth with David Nelson
Browns Need to Learn from Past Draft Mistakes
Browns Release Chris Gocong and Usama Young
Browns Missing on Grimes Disappointing, But Not The End
Cleveland Indians: Evaluating The Rest Of The Free Agent Starting Pitchers
Offseason Rundown: Gettin' the Platoon Back Together; Smith Signs with Angels
View from the Porch: Offseason Markets Taking Shape
Indians Strengthen Outfield With David Murphy
Drew Stubbs, Ryan Raburn, And The Indians' Right Field Situation
The TCF Forums
(Monday, December 09 2013 8:12 AM)
BCS Bowl Forecast
(Monday, December 09 2013 12:47 AM)
B1G Title Game: Win and You're In!
(Monday, December 09 2013 12:38 AM)
Browns vs Patriots
(Sunday, December 08 2013 9:02 PM)
2014 College QB Thread
(Sunday, December 08 2013 6:36 PM)
JPs 2013 Pick 17
(Sunday, December 08 2013 2:11 PM)
The 2014 Offseason Thread
(Sunday, December 08 2013 11:02 AM)
The Walking Dead, tv series
(Sunday, December 08 2013 1:55 AM)
TTUN "the game" week
(Sunday, December 08 2013 12:45 AM)
What kind of beer you been drinkin' lately?
(Saturday, December 07 2013 6:27 PM)
The Daily Dish
Indians Prospect Insider
Wait 'Til Next Year (Benz)
Lets Go Tribe
64 and Counting
The Wine & Gold Rush
Mistake By The Lake
Cavs Random Thoughts
Forest City Fanatics
Waves of Arms
The Tribe Daily
Cleveland Film News
Deep in the Q
Copyright 2010 TheClevelandFan, LLC
Scroll To Top