Meet The Writers
He never won the big one. He never even played for the big one. That tagline might follow Marty Schottenheimer around for the rest of his days. His failure to get a team to the Super Bowl in 21 NFL head coaching seasons is the most famously infamous line on his resume. But Marty has some very redeeming qualities as well. And has consistently taken teams with little talent and made them winners wherever he has been. Erik Cassano talks Marty in his latest piece for us.
He never won the big one. He never even played for the big one.
might follow Marty
around for the rest of his days. His failure to get a team to the Super Bowl in 21 NFL head coaching seasons is the most famously infamous line on his resume.
The fact that during his tenure coaching the Browns, he presided over two of the most spectacular playoff
in team history -- you know them as "The Drive" and "The Fumble" -- might cause you to proceed with caution when warming to the idea of giving the 65-year-old a second crack at resurrecting Cleveland professional football.
And to that, I say: If you're worried about what might happen should the Browns reach another AFC Championship Game, someone needs to check your garage for paint fumes. Give me The Drive and The Fumble any year over the decade-long procession of failure that has been the Cleveland Browns since 1999.
Rumor has it
wants back in the coaching game, and he'd be interested in a second tenure with the Browns -- though he has vaguely denied an interest in a return to coaching on several occasions, most recently Thursday night on NFL Network.
Not that denials are to be 100 percent believed. Generally, money talks and other stuff walks in the world of professional sports.
is likely no exception.
to the the Rooney family and
Nation is strong enough to withstand the gobs of cash Randy Lerner appears poised to throw at him after the season,
is a worthy (if nearly as expensive) Option 1A.
There is an overwhelming reason why: wins and losses.
has far more of the former than the latter.
has a career 200-126-1 coaching record. In 21 seasons with the Browns, Chiefs, Redskins and Chargers, he's led a team to a losing record only twice. His teams have won double-digit games 11 times. He's won eight division titles.
body of work can be judged outside of the context of one team. With few exceptions, he's won wherever he's gone.
He's won with quarterbacks ranging from Bernie
to Joe Montana, Steve
to Rich Gannon to Elvis
and Philip Rivers. He's won with running backs ranging from Kevin Mack and Earnest
, Barry Word, Marcus Allen and
Different players, different systems, different styles.
has adapted to his resources and kept winning.
The belief here is that
would be an excellent foundation-building coach for this Browns team, which has a decent amount of talent, but lacks discipline, fundamentals and a collective identity.
is a coach who can step in and establish instant credibility with his players, something Romeo
appears to have done only by playing the role of Mr. Nice Guy. Where players like
, they'd be forced to respect someone like
. The respect factor is obviously absent from the current coach-player relationship in the Browns locker room, no matter how many players stick up for
would bring a dominant personality to the head coach's position, and a sense of law and order will likely follow. You don't last more than two decades as an NFL coach without being good at developing discipline in your players, eradicating mistakes and sloppy play, and getting everyone focused on a common set of goals.
Twenty-one seasons as a coach says
understands that in order to build an army, you need to build soldiers. Right now, the Browns are more like a ragtag militia.
Of course, there would be a catch to Marty's second tenure as Browns coach: It likely wouldn't last more than a few years. At 65, it's reasonable to wonder how much gas
has left in the tank. Three or four years of organization-building might be enough to drain the remaining juice out of
That's why, should he be hired as Browns coach,
would need a very specific short-term goal: To turn the foundation of the Browns organization from quicksand to concrete.
would be called in to lay the framework for future success by reforming the team's football operations (which might or might not include the assistance of Phil Savage or another general manager), getting rid of the rampant fundamental flaws currently plaguing the team on and off the field, and developing a well-defined team identity.
All the while,
would need to be developing a successor -- maybe son Brian, currently the offensive coordinator of the Jets. His successor could then hopefully build upon the foundation laid by
and turn the Browns into a perennial contender.
A great coaching system is what teams like Patriots and
have, and what teams like the Browns need. And when you get right down to it, save for a rough-around-the-edges Bill
, the last time a Browns coach developed anything resembling a successful system was
nearly 25 years ago.
The other major drawback to
is his checkered history with the management of teams he's worked for. Friction with Art
over a lack of an offensive coordinator paved his way out of Cleveland in 1988. Redskins owner Dan Snyder fired
after one season in Washington to make way for Steve
relationship with Chargers president Dean
was notoriously icy, and ultimately led to his firing after a 14-2 season in 2006.
In much the same way it would be difficult to envision Savage and
coexisting for long, it would be difficult to envision Savage and
sharing space without stepping on each other's toes. Whose side you take would depend on whether you believe talent evaluation or coaching is more important to a team's success.
The most important quality the next Browns head coach can possess is a track record of success as an NFL head coach. It appears that Randy Lerner concurs on that point. But beyond that, it's time for Lerner to dig a bit deeper and look at how the success of his coaching candidates has been achieved.
A candidate from a successful organization does not always equal a successful hire. Carmen Policy, Dwight Clark, Chris Palmer, Butch Davis, Savage and
have all proved that to greater and lesser degrees.
has 15 seasons and 149 victories with the
as his main selling point. But until he successfully runs a second NFL team, the eternal debate will rage on whether he was the generator or beneficiary of a rock-solid organization in Pittsburgh.
Viewed through that lens,
is something of a safer pick than
to lead the Browns out of the doldrums. He developed perennial winners in three of his four NFL coaching stops, which means there is reason to believe he could once again develop the Browns into a winner -- or at the very least, do the dirty work of organizational muck removal.
Dec 04, 2008 7:00 PM
Tweets by @TheClevelandFan
NBA Announces 2013-2014 Schedule
Browns Ink Sharknado
Sharknado A No-Show For Rookie Camp
Trent Richardson Out Until Training Camp
Browns Sign Brandon Jackson
Carrasco Suspended Eight Games
Browns Add to Wide Receiver Depth with David Nelson
Browns Need to Learn from Past Draft Mistakes
Browns Release Chris Gocong and Usama Young
Browns Missing on Grimes Disappointing, But Not The End
The Numbing Sameness of it All, Again--Patriots Edition
Patriots Plus Refs Equals Another Browns Loss
Rob Chudzinski Has His Welcome To Cleveland Moment
The Tackle That Ruined A Season
NFL Outsider - Week Fourteen Picks
The TCF Forums
2014 College QB Thread
(Friday, December 13 2013 1:25 AM)
(Thursday, December 12 2013 8:24 PM)
(Thursday, December 12 2013 5:00 PM)
The real draft
(Thursday, December 12 2013 2:29 PM)
JPs 2013 Pick 17
(Thursday, December 12 2013 10:05 AM)
(Wednesday, December 11 2013 9:45 PM)
The 2014 Offseason Thread
(Wednesday, December 11 2013 5:58 PM)
What kind of beer you been drinkin' lately?
(Wednesday, December 11 2013 5:26 PM)
B1G Title Game: Win and You're In!
(Wednesday, December 11 2013 11:00 AM)
(Wednesday, December 11 2013 9:07 AM)
The Daily Dish
Indians Prospect Insider
Wait 'Til Next Year (Benz)
Lets Go Tribe
64 and Counting
The Wine & Gold Rush
Mistake By The Lake
Cavs Random Thoughts
Forest City Fanatics
Waves of Arms
The Tribe Daily
Cleveland Film News
Deep in the Q
Copyright 2010 TheClevelandFan, LLC
Scroll To Top