e0y2e3 wrote:Look, PP, I respect you, but no it is not arguable.
It's not even in the realm of arguable. Every single economist and urban planning mind in the country has called bullshit on that giant turd of a fallacy you just laid. The numbers (supported by pre/post expansion data and inter-city upgrade data) support nothing you claim there. Just like the numbers support a shitty Casino giving C-town a 1-2 year bounce that then dies.
You're smart and well read, I recommend you read up on this. The article on question starts giving you links to the wormhole.
And calling out the tax paying absurd repair costs while ignoring the initial investment the city made is just shitty math.
Cleveland, like many others, got swindled.
Frankly, NYC ended all of this when they refused the Jets relocation project. Then things were cool for four years and Jerry Jones decided to fuck it all up again.....
Any city in America that pays for a stadium is retarded (as in learning disabled retarded). This has been proven at this point.
SD:
Your argument is the classic foolishness , that discounts the immutable fact ,
That
Perception is reality .
Because Buffalo has the Bills , they are relevant , without them , they would be a pimple on the ass of a blotch on a map even with Niagarra Falls in the back drop .
Cleveland remains relevant because of their sports , in a city which has lost much of its manufacturing and population , three sports teams still provide it with Big City cachet around the Country .
The bean counting miscreants which discount the value of a sports team to a Cities reputation and status are the fools who value Saber Metric stats over a triple Crown winner whose actual play was part and parcel to leading his team to the playoffs .
Wither Green Bay without the Packers , and eat that with shit on your point and stats about costs , it means nothing in the political wastes of gubernment .
Nobody gives a damn , its money spent in their neighborhoods which would get wasted smewhere else.
Then perception eclipses reality .
Now put that in your pocket protector and smoke it .
SoulDawg