peeker643 wrote:Cerebral_DownTime wrote:Confusing "lazy" argument with easy.
Answer my question and we can talk.Hypothetical situation as I really don't care who wins:
Cabrera hits .340, 40 HRs and 130RBI, average or less defense, 10SBs
Trout hits .340, 38HRs and 125RBI w/GG defense and 40SBs
Does Triple Crown still win there as well?
Same numbers as above but Miggy is a DH only- Does Triple Crown still mean MVP there?
Miggy is first Triple Crown Winner since 1967 and Verlander wins 27 games on that same team. Still Miggy?
Yes. He is still the MVP.
You can add all the made up scenarios and whatnot. This year it's still Miggy. No question.
"If the moon exploded and made gravity less on west coast and Trout hits 95 HRs, but Miggy hits 50 in normal gravity, who IS MVP NOW?".