Govbarney wrote:I think this Idea of the unyielding faith of Browns fans is a bit of a over exaggeration, I would almost call it a Myth.
From about March through October all you hear is Browns town, and about this almost nazi like loyalty of the 70,000 screaming fans every Sunday through rain, snow, and sleet.
If this where true why do I see so much Black and Gold when we play the Steeler's on Sunday in December, or the empty upper decks after Halloween, and why did my father have to buy a 4 story antenna to get a signal from Pittsburgh, Buffalo, and London Ontario in the eighties (when they where a hell of a lot better then they are now, and the tickets and beer were alot cheaper).
It all comes down to winning; If the Browns win , then that eye sore on the shores of Lake Erie becomes pandamoniom palace, they lose then you cant give the tickets away for free.
I think the same holds true for the Tribe. Cleveland fans are smart enough to know if it looks like shit, smells like shit , and tastes like shit, well then it probably is shit regardless of what the record was in April, May, and June.
The Browns start off drawing until they suck. Then the exodus happens, but every year there is a ground swell of support until lost.
The Indians don't get that credit and extension of faith, and now they don't even get attendance when they win.
I'm not even sure that I understand this alleged "debate". So Imina go Rammy on this.
1. Average Cleveland fan views the Dolan ownership on about the same favorability level as Congress. You can say that is unfair and make a case against, you can say average Cleveland fan is ignant, but it is what it is. Nothing short of post season and sustained winning seasons is gonna get this town amped and even then attendance won't be "great".
2. Cleveland is a football region. Get over it. It just is. It's in the blood. Plenty of markets this size support NFL & MLB, so this harping on the Browns like as if this is sum zero is ignorant. Leave them out of it. If the Tribe can't draw it is on the Tribe and the fans.
3. Cleveland is not a good baseball town. It just isn't. You can yell "455" to me until yer blue in the face and we all know the perfect storm that created that. We all know Cleveland is no Cincinnati, St. Louis or KC as a baseball town. Having said that, it should still bebetter than 30th in attandance. See the note on the Dolans.
4. Given the current players, the Indians have as much marketability as salt. cab't help but contrastthem to the young Pirates Huntington has build becasue he can F'ing draft worth a damn.
5. None of this is Chris Perez's cross to bear even though he's right. Nothing he's doing off the mound is remotely productive.