danwismar wrote:Squints wrote:I was unaware of the close relationship between Urban and Bruce. Was Urbs on his staff while he was HC?
That is right...and they have stayed in touch and grown much closer over the years.
Did they shower together?
Moderators: peeker643, swerb, danwismar, furls
by General » Wed Nov 16, 2011 4:06 pm
danwismar wrote:Squints wrote:I was unaware of the close relationship between Urban and Bruce. Was Urbs on his staff while he was HC?
That is right...and they have stayed in touch and grown much closer over the years.

by danwismar » Wed Nov 16, 2011 6:24 pm
jb wrote:Not to be argumentative, and this is not personal. It is merely reflective of reading concenses. But for a couple years I've read this n that about how awesome these OSU recruits were supposed to be when they were comitted. Frankly they kinda suck to me.
Sabino, Sweat, Kline, Berry, I could give 'em all a big fat "meh". Don't even start me on the OL. The RB's, the WR's, they all suck. Boom herron is the nbest they got, and he's a better version of "meh". Shazier impresses me as a young player, and Simon is the only legit baller on D that I see, but I digress. Purdue kicked their collective overrated 4 star asses in a game that had no business being close.
Is that all on Fickel? Is he Faust? I think not. Teddy the Wonderlizzard could coach a great collection of college talent and they don't lose 5 games against a mediocre BCS schedule.
So I now call BS on the Buckeye recruiting efforts over the past several years other than Peezy.
by furls » Wed Nov 16, 2011 8:56 pm
jb wrote:furls wrote:Tressel, as boring and unhip as he was, was already cherry picking the very best in PA, Indiana, Michigan and Illinois (to a lesser extent).
Not to be argumentative, and this is not personal. It is merely reflective of reading concenses. But for a couple years I've read this n that about how awesome these OSU recruits were supposed to be when they were comitted. Frankly they kinda suck to me.
Sabino, Sweat, Kline, Berry, I could give 'em all a big fat "meh". Don't even start me on the OL. The RB's, the WR's, they all suck. Boom herron is the nbest they got, and he's a better version of "meh". Shazier impresses me as a young player, and Simon is the only legit baller on D that I see, but I digress. Purdue kicked their collective overrated 4 star asses in a game that had no business being close.
Is that all on Fickel? Is he Faust? I think not. Teddy the Wonderlizzard could coach a great collection of college talent and they don't lose 5 games against a mediocre BCS schedule.
So I now call BS on the Buckeye recruiting efforts over the past several years other than Peezy.
by furls » Wed Nov 16, 2011 9:03 pm
danwismar wrote:jb wrote:Not to be argumentative, and this is not personal. It is merely reflective of reading concenses. But for a couple years I've read this n that about how awesome these OSU recruits were supposed to be when they were comitted. Frankly they kinda suck to me.
Sabino, Sweat, Kline, Berry, I could give 'em all a big fat "meh". Don't even start me on the OL. The RB's, the WR's, they all suck. Boom herron is the nbest they got, and he's a better version of "meh". Shazier impresses me as a young player, and Simon is the only legit baller on D that I see, but I digress. Purdue kicked their collective overrated 4 star asses in a game that had no business being close.
Is that all on Fickel? Is he Faust? I think not. Teddy the Wonderlizzard could coach a great collection of college talent and they don't lose 5 games against a mediocre BCS schedule.
So I now call BS on the Buckeye recruiting efforts over the past several years other than Peezy.
Fair points all. A couple of thoughts in response...
If JT and his staff misjudged the talent they were getting, then so did everyone else. His classes were, with the exception of a year or two, rated very high by the people who get paid to rate such things. I have made the case for the last few years that the Big Ten was not and is not getting the elite players in the country...you can look at the rankings of H.S. players by position and you'll sometimes go ten or twenty deep at any given position before you get to a kid who has committed to a B1G school.
That is always qualified here, legitimately so, by Furls and others, that the rating services have a bias in favor of kids from the south and west...so be it. But the gradual demographic shift to those regions is having an undeniable effect on where the talent is being "grown"...and proximity to home is still the No. 1 factor in a player's choice of college destination.
None of that, however, explains losing to fucking Purdue, as you suggest. There is the other bias that comes into play here too...recruiting experts take their cues from what kids the big programs are interested in. Is OSU recruiting Devin Bogard because he is highly rated...or is he highly rated because OSU is recruiting him? So much of recruiting ratings is total derivative bullshit.
No argument whatsoever that OL recruiting has been, and is still a clusterfuck. That is a vicious circle effect. Kids see next to no Ohio State OL's developing into NFL linemen, so the ones with NFL aspirations and abilities don't want to go there. The same could be said for TE's. Also, the Bollman-is-an-idiot factor...he takes OL's that were high school A-A's and turns out crap lines year after year.
I would also caution not putting too much weight on this aberration of a season. Remember that JT in his last two seasons won two BT titles and two BCS bowl games and had a total of 3 losses in two years and finished top 5. His recruits were (almost the only) exceptions to the Big Ten's second-class recruiting status (i.e. Miller, Miller, Grant, Grant)in the most recent class.
All that said, I blame coaching as much as recruiting for the "underachieving"...especially on offense. I don't need to rant on Bollman (any more). His ineptitude has been on painful display for years...with JT's tacit approval. There is better talent on offense than the scheme allows to show. I've become convinced that Paul Warfield and Jerry Rice couldn't thrive in this Cro-Magnon offense with the junior-high passing scheme they run down there. There are a lot of BCS schools that would love to have Devin Smith, Evan Spencer, Verlon Reed and even Fields and Williams...all with at least three years of eligibility remaining. The combination of a freshman QB and a hopelessly weak scheme makes the talent look way worse than it is, IMO. Also the RB's are not Beanie Wells or Eddie George.
On defense, the lack of stud linebackers is obvious...Heacock got the most out of the Homan, Rolle types, but for sure Klein and Sabino are a step down even from that level. I forgive this year's secondary for being painfully young, although I was sure the safety play would be much improved this year, and I've been disappointed so far. They've had some great secondaries there in the last decade, but this year's isn't one of them...but they'll get better.
It has just worked out this year that the DL is playing four defensive tackles on the line...the coaches say it's the way to get their best four guys on the field...but the fact remains there isn't a classic DE on the roster good enough to crack the starting lineup right now...and that's pathetic.
I think this year's freshman class has a ton of blue-chip talent in it...from D. Smith, both Grants, Shazier, Bennett, Braxton. The future seems a lot brighter when you think that only Sweat and Moeller are lost off this defense, and guys like Josh Perry and Bogard and others are joining it.
by danwismar » Wed Nov 16, 2011 11:57 pm
by Cerebral_DownTime » Thu Nov 17, 2011 12:00 am
by JCoz » Thu Nov 17, 2011 4:45 pm
danwismar wrote:Who knows...if Meyer comes to OSU, maybe Sharif Floyd will believe another dream story and come along with him.
by JCoz » Thu Nov 17, 2011 5:03 pm
jb wrote:furls wrote:Tressel, as boring and unhip as he was, was already cherry picking the very best in PA, Indiana, Michigan and Illinois (to a lesser extent).
Not to be argumentative, and this is not personal. It is merely reflective of reading concenses. But for a couple years I've read this n that about how awesome these OSU recruits were supposed to be when they were comitted. Frankly they kinda suck to me.
Sabino, Sweat, Kline, Berry, I could give 'em all a big fat "meh". Don't even start me on the OL. The RB's, the WR's, they all suck. Boom herron is the nbest they got, and he's a better version of "meh". Shazier impresses me as a young player, and Simon is the only legit baller on D that I see, but I digress. Purdue kicked their collective overrated 4 star asses in a game that had no business being close.
Is that all on Fickel? Is he Faust? I think not. Teddy the Wonderlizzard could coach a great collection of college talent and they don't lose 5 games against a mediocre BCS schedule.
So I now call BS on the Buckeye recruiting efforts over the past several years other than Peezy.
by Sea Foam Green » Thu Nov 17, 2011 6:14 pm
JCoz wrote:Dan that article was a POS hackjob though. Read it a while back.
It wasn't just last year, for years and years and years Urban brought in fantastic classes. Muschamp might not have what he wants but he has plenty of talent. Urban didn't have what he wanted but he won with Zookers talent.
Muschamp might just be a shitty head coach. Thats the reality that UF fans have to accept as a possibility at this point IMO. Maybe he's a fantastic HC but needs his particular ideal players for his system. But the idea that there isn't enough talent in gainsville right now to avoid looking like a giant stinking pile of shit is......just denial IMO.
by JCoz » Thu Nov 17, 2011 7:10 pm
Sea Foam Green wrote:JCoz wrote:Dan that article was a POS hackjob though. Read it a while back.
It wasn't just last year, for years and years and years Urban brought in fantastic classes. Muschamp might not have what he wants but he has plenty of talent. Urban didn't have what he wanted but he won with Zookers talent.
Muschamp might just be a shitty head coach. Thats the reality that UF fans have to accept as a possibility at this point IMO. Maybe he's a fantastic HC but needs his particular ideal players for his system. But the idea that there isn't enough talent in gainsville right now to avoid looking like a giant stinking pile of shit is......just denial IMO.
Is Muschamp so bad that he made them suck last year too?
I'm not going to defend Muschamp, and I especially don't want to stick up for Weis, but the problems the Gators have this year are similar to those they had last year. QB & OL. I think they have decent play makers at the skill positions, but it doesn't matter.
Now is it Meyer's fault Brantley is a piece of shit? He was highly rated, so probably not. Did he neglect recruiting the O-line? I don't know, maybe....but whatever the reason, the end result is they suck, and you can't blame it all on Muschamp because they showed every sign of sucking last year under Meyer.
by gnati » Thu Nov 17, 2011 7:14 pm
by JCoz » Thu Nov 17, 2011 7:18 pm
by furls » Thu Nov 17, 2011 7:26 pm
by skatingtripods » Thu Nov 17, 2011 8:48 pm
by leadpipe » Thu Nov 17, 2011 9:12 pm
gnati wrote:He isn't named after a Pope, doesn't have "health issues", probably isn't pre-programed into Herby's phone, but tell me like I am a 5 year old why Mel Tucker doesn't get any run as a potential candidate?
http://www.jaguars.com/team/coaches/Mel ... 28e61f09a7
From Ohio - Check
Played in the Big Ten - Check
Coached in the Big Ten - Check
Coached at tOSU - Check
Coached in the NFL - Check
Coordinator in NFL - Check
Interviewed for at least two NFL HC Jobs - Check
What am I missing? A 39 year old African American with Ohio and Ohio State ties that is accomplished enough to get NFL HC looks...and he isn't even in the discussion?
Two potential draw backs:
No HC experience - which obviously can go either way, alot of guys with previous experice suck hind tit.
Perhaps wants to hold out for NFL - a legit concern.
Other than that, what am I missing?
by Triple-S » Thu Nov 17, 2011 9:57 pm
Swerb wrote:Go start a blog if you want to tell the world your incomprehendible ramblings.
Cerebral_DownTime wrote:I have a big arm and can throw the ball pretty damn far...... maybe even over those moutains. The Browns should sign me, i'll let you all in locker room to drink beer. Then we can all go out the parking lot to watch me do motorcycle stunts.

by googleeph2 » Thu Nov 17, 2011 10:03 pm
Triple-S wrote:realfreemancbs mike freeman
Scout.com is reporting Urban Meyer has agreed to coach OSU for 7 years, $35 million. If true, whoa.
9 minutes ago Favorite Retweet Reply
FUCK YEAH.
by e0y2e3 » Thu Nov 17, 2011 10:45 pm

by pup » Thu Nov 17, 2011 11:29 pm
by Cerebral_DownTime » Thu Nov 17, 2011 11:32 pm
pup wrote:It might not "be true" right now.
But it is true.
And Mel Tucker is a great choice, if the best guy in the business is not available or interested. Which he is. And is.
by pup » Thu Nov 17, 2011 11:49 pm
Cerebral_DownTime wrote:pup wrote:It might not "be true" right now.
But it is true.
And Mel Tucker is a great choice, if the best guy in the business is not available or interested. Which he is. And is.
Pup, what makes you so sure he'll be coaching OSU next year?
by danwismar » Fri Nov 18, 2011 12:31 am
pup wrote:Because I believe he wants to. And if he wants to, there is no way he doesn't.
I believe he sees what Jim Tressel did with tOSU and believes in his heart of hearts that he is at least on par as a recruiter and better on game day than Tressel was. So he sees it as an opportunity to walk in and absolutely dominate the Big 10. And add about 110 more wins, probably 7+ BCS games and multiple NC game opportunities over the next decade. Cementing himself in the world of the best to have worn the headset. Certainly at the top of the list for this generation.
I think he sees an offense that is pretty well off in terms of his style QB, young guys with room to grow on the outside and a couple of RB that may not be Eddie George, but can certainly carry the load in his offense.
It is just plain to see to me. Maybe I am wrong. I have no direct knowledge of anything. He is an egomaniac HC with a prime opportunity to land where he belongs. We are a desperate program looking to get back to the top with more money than just about any other program in the country.
by pup » Fri Nov 18, 2011 12:33 am
danwismar wrote:pup wrote:Because I believe he wants to. And if he wants to, there is no way he doesn't.
I believe he sees what Jim Tressel did with tOSU and believes in his heart of hearts that he is at least on par as a recruiter and better on game day than Tressel was. So he sees it as an opportunity to walk in and absolutely dominate the Big 10. And add about 110 more wins, probably 7+ BCS games and multiple NC game opportunities over the next decade. Cementing himself in the world of the best to have worn the headset. Certainly at the top of the list for this generation.
I think he sees an offense that is pretty well off in terms of his style QB, young guys with room to grow on the outside and a couple of RB that may not be Eddie George, but can certainly carry the load in his offense.
It is just plain to see to me. Maybe I am wrong. I have no direct knowledge of anything. He is an egomaniac HC with a prime opportunity to land where he belongs. We are a desperate program looking to get back to the top with more money than just about any other program in the country.
Then there's that portrait of Woody Hayes that he has hanging on the wall in his family room.
by danwismar » Fri Nov 18, 2011 12:33 am
by pup » Fri Nov 18, 2011 12:37 am
danwismar wrote:BTW, no one at Scout can figure out who the hell they are talking about reporting a deal and contract terms for UM. No one at Scout has reported any such thing...as eO said above.
by Cerebral_DownTime » Fri Nov 18, 2011 1:16 am
by pup » Fri Nov 18, 2011 1:18 am
Cerebral_DownTime wrote:I have a dog named "Roman", it doesn't mean I'm joining the Legion.
by Cerebral_DownTime » Fri Nov 18, 2011 1:27 am
by pup » Fri Nov 18, 2011 1:42 am
Cerebral_DownTime wrote:So is this 11 warriors stuff about being 99.7% sure that popped up on my tweeting page for reals?
by Cerebral_DownTime » Fri Nov 18, 2011 1:45 am
We are 99.7% sure Urban Meyer has agreed to a deal to become the next coach of Ohio State. Solid sources. Plural.
by pup » Fri Nov 18, 2011 1:50 am
Cerebral_DownTime wrote:We are 99.7% sure Urban Meyer has agreed to a deal to become the next coach of Ohio State. Solid sources. Plural.
Retwittered by SSS.
by Cerebral_DownTime » Fri Nov 18, 2011 1:55 am
by YahooFanChicago » Fri Nov 18, 2011 4:47 am
by jb » Fri Nov 18, 2011 11:04 am
by jb » Fri Nov 18, 2011 11:07 am
Cerebral_DownTime wrote:I have a dog named "Roman", it doesn't mean I'm joining the Legion.
by jb » Fri Nov 18, 2011 11:08 am
danwismar wrote:Then there's that portrait of Woody Hayes that he has hanging on the wall in his family room.
by JCoz » Fri Nov 18, 2011 11:25 am
jb wrote:And Hankins would be what opinion suggest he is were he to do some real S&C. Right now he's not active on enough plays. I'll stick by my tak ethat Simon is the best player on D right now and best Sunday prospect.
by JCoz » Fri Nov 18, 2011 12:31 pm
by danwismar » Fri Nov 18, 2011 12:39 pm
jb wrote:Lastly, if there is a silver lining to Tatgate, it is that I will never have to see another Bollman offesnse as long as I live. haven't been this happy for a transition since Coletto went to West Lafayette.
by dmiles » Fri Nov 18, 2011 12:53 pm


by googleeph2 » Fri Nov 18, 2011 12:54 pm
googleeph2 wrote:Triple-S wrote:realfreemancbs mike freeman
Scout.com is reporting Urban Meyer has agreed to coach OSU for 7 years, $35 million. If true, whoa.
9 minutes ago Favorite Retweet Reply
FUCK YEAH.
If true, SSS is my new favorite poster
by JCoz » Fri Nov 18, 2011 1:11 pm
dmiles wrote:O-Line type of OC. I am guessing he's better than Bollman in that regard.
by fundamentals » Fri Nov 18, 2011 1:39 pm
Cerebral_DownTime wrote:Urban Meyer isn't ever going to coach at OSU. Not ever.

by motherscratcher » Fri Nov 18, 2011 1:44 pm
fundamentals wrote:A wise man named CDT once said this....................Cerebral_DownTime wrote:Urban Meyer isn't ever going to coach at OSU. Not ever.
That was earlier this year when there were several maintaining the Urban Renewal Plan at tOSU. Still think that now?
I was hoping Urban would have a handshake deal already in place.
by fundamentals » Fri Nov 18, 2011 1:46 pm
motherscratcher wrote:fundamentals wrote:A wise man named CDT once said this....................Cerebral_DownTime wrote:Urban Meyer isn't ever going to coach at OSU. Not ever.
That was earlier this year when there were several maintaining the Urban Renewal Plan at tOSU. Still think that now?
I was hoping Urban would have a handshake deal already in place.
CDT was right. I don't think Meyer is going to end up at Oklahoma State. I think he's a lock for tOSU.
See what I did there?

by MOSER » Fri Nov 18, 2011 2:09 pm
by danwismar » Fri Nov 18, 2011 5:35 pm
by fundamentals » Fri Nov 18, 2011 7:16 pm

by Cerebral_DownTime » Fri Nov 18, 2011 7:43 pm
by Cerebral_DownTime » Fri Nov 18, 2011 8:19 pm
jb wrote:Cerebral_DownTime wrote:I have a dog named "Roman", it doesn't mean I'm joining the Legion.
Becasue you would be slaughtered on the worng side in Germania.
Return to College Sports Arena
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests
