by furls » Sun Sep 05, 2010 1:54 pm
If the Bucks beat TCU or BSU then the championship wouldn't "count." The Buckeyes victory in the media would be a function of beating an overrated TCU/BSU team. I am not sure that even a playoff solves the problem because please, make the case to me that an undefeated TCU/BYU/BSU deserves a berth in the playoffs as conference champs over the #2 team in the SEC, Big Ten or Big XII.
If the Buckeyes played BSU or TCU's schedule they would face the national media rath and ridicule of the ages. How does BSU get a pass? If they want to play in the NCG then schedule Alabama, OSU, VaTech, and LSU. The rest of their schedule is a complete pass, so scheduling one good team, one mediocre team, one bottom of the barrel bowl team, and a MAC bottom feeder should not get it done if the rest of your schedule is shit.
Let's compare OSU's and BSU's schedule for a minute:
BSU has VaTech, OSU has Miami (these two cancel)
BSU has Wyoming, OSU has Marshall (these two cancel as both were bottom of the barrel bowl teams last year)
BSU has Toledo, OSU has Ohio University (slight edge to OSU, but I will be generous and call it a wash)
BSU has Oregon St., OSU has Eastern Michigan (Clear Advantage BSU)
Now where is BSU's equivalent to:
Iowa?
Wisconsin?
Penn State?
We can sit here and argue the merits of Purdue vs. Nevada, or Minnesota vs. Fresno St., but in the end BSU will not play anyone in league this year that is even close to those 3. Finishing 47-4 is super neato, now go play more than one fucking meaningful regular season game per year.
Loo,
You hit the nail on the head. Now TCU has an inside track to a BCS game (particularly now that SOS is not a factor). What is worse is that they will try to justify it with Andy Dalton's ridiculous stats accumulated at the expense of the New Mexico and SDSU and a rush defense that made its bones by holding the likes of Colorado State or UNLV to 43 YPG. Stats without context are just numbers and most media pundits are too lazy to weight the numbers accordingly. Now all that said, TCU has a much tougher road that BSU in conference: BYU, Utah and Air Force are at least decent teams. The WAC fucking SUCKS! In either case, neither team deserves to be in the championship game until they beat at least something resembling a real BCS conference schedule, if they got to go out of conference to get well then so be it.
Coming from a Wolverine, we're the football equivalent of a formerly abused wife of a meth addict who just remarried the safe nice guy. We're just glad we have someone who's aware that it's a rivalry and that tackling on defense is integral. Baby steps.
-Kingpin74