Moderators: peeker643, swerb, Ziner
by jack_tors » Tue Jul 15, 2008 10:18 pm
by peeker643 » Tue Jul 15, 2008 11:44 pm
by CP » Wed Jul 16, 2008 1:24 am
by swerb » Wed Jul 16, 2008 8:19 am
by Ziner » Wed Jul 16, 2008 10:32 am
by jfiling » Wed Jul 16, 2008 10:35 am
by Ziner » Wed Jul 16, 2008 10:40 am
jfiling wrote:I can come up with plenty of reasons where the alleged could claim self-defense. Can you tell me why a guy would allow a cop to cuff him, in a situation where you would presume you are on camera, except the dipshit Twinsburg cops apparently have cars like this one with non-working cameras (and I have my suspicions about that), and then shoot him with a registered firearm when he had no criminal record? It all stinks, but hey, let's take the dead cops side and fry this guy before having any idea what actually happened.
by pup » Wed Jul 16, 2008 10:41 am
jfiling wrote:I can come up with plenty of reasons where the alleged could claim self-defense. Can you tell me why a guy would allow a cop to cuff him, in a situation where you would presume you are on camera, except the dipshit Twinsburg cops apparently have cars like this one with non-working cameras (and I have my suspicions about that), and then shoot him with a registered firearm when he had no criminal record? It all stinks, but hey, let's take the dead cops side and fry this guy before having any idea what actually happened.
by peeker643 » Wed Jul 16, 2008 10:58 am
jfiling wrote:I can come up with plenty of reasons where the alleged could claim self-defense. Can you tell me why a guy would allow a cop to cuff him, in a situation where you would presume you are on camera, except the dipshit Twinsburg cops apparently have cars like this one with non-working cameras (and I have my suspicions about that), and then shoot him with a registered firearm when he had no criminal record? It all stinks, but hey, let's take the dead cops side and fry this guy before having any idea what actually happened.
by swerb » Wed Jul 16, 2008 11:07 am
by skatingtripods » Wed Jul 16, 2008 4:01 pm
jfiling wrote:I can come up with plenty of reasons where the alleged could claim self-defense. Can you tell me why a guy would allow a cop to cuff him, in a situation where you would presume you are on camera, except the dipshit Twinsburg cops apparently have cars like this one with non-working cameras (and I have my suspicions about that), and then shoot him with a registered firearm when he had no criminal record? It all stinks, but hey, let's take the dead cops side and fry this guy before having any idea what actually happened.
by leadpipe » Wed Jul 16, 2008 5:39 pm
by CP » Wed Jul 16, 2008 6:32 pm
Skating Tripods wrote:Are you fucking kidding me with this bullshit? The police officer had his German shepherd ready and willing in the backseat and made no move to get him out. His gun was holstered, as many have said, and it was a traffic stop with someone assumed to be under the influence and probably belligerent.
Not to mention, dipshit, this cop forgot to put a tape in what was an old system in his car. Many of the Twinsburg cruisers have digital recording technology, his just happened not to. This is straight from the Twinsburg PD when some of their men were on Trivosonno the other day.
This fucking scumbag should rot. I don't give a shit if he has a criminal record or not. HE KILLED A POLICE OFFICER. He could be the nicest guy in the world, would do anything for anybody, but if you kill a cop, fuck you.
God forbid a police officer ever have to do anything for you or your family and get killed in the line of duty.
Give this asshole the benefit of the doubt. While the fallen officer's 3-month-old and wife try to piece their lives back together. Now she gets to answer the question every parent hates to answer. "What happened to Daddy (or Mommy)?" Think about that before you spew a bunch of bullshit.
by Apex777 » Wed Jul 16, 2008 6:39 pm
jfiling wrote:I can come up with plenty of reasons where the alleged could claim self-defense. Can you tell me why a guy would allow a cop to cuff him, in a situation where you would presume you are on camera, except the dipshit Twinsburg cops apparently have cars like this one with non-working cameras (and I have my suspicions about that), and then shoot him with a registered firearm when he had no criminal record? It all stinks, but hey, let's take the dead cops side and fry this guy before having any idea what actually happened.

by jfiling » Wed Jul 16, 2008 7:54 pm
This fucking scumbag should rot. I don't give a shit if he has a criminal record or not. HE KILLED A POLICE OFFICER. He could be the nicest guy in the world, would do anything for anybody, but if you kill a cop, fuck you.
by Dozen » Wed Jul 16, 2008 7:56 pm
by Dozen » Wed Jul 16, 2008 7:58 pm
jfiling wrote:I can come up with plenty of reasons where the alleged could claim self-defense. Can you tell me why a guy would allow a cop to cuff him, in a situation where you would presume you are on camera, except the dipshit Twinsburg cops apparently have cars like this one with non-working cameras (and I have my suspicions about that), and then shoot him with a registered firearm when he had no criminal record? It all stinks, but hey, let's take the dead cops side and fry this guy before having any idea what actually happened.
by peeker643 » Wed Jul 16, 2008 8:55 pm
jfiling wrote:This fucking scumbag should rot. I don't give a shit if he has a criminal record or not. HE KILLED A POLICE OFFICER. He could be the nicest guy in the world, would do anything for anybody, but if you kill a cop, fuck you.
I'm not going to respond to the personal attacks, but this one really gets me, because there is an innocent man sitting in prison for life due to this exact scenario. Cory Maye was sleeping in his home with his daughter when the cops raided his home. It was the wrong home, by the way. Fearing for his daughter's life, he shielded her with his body, grabbed his gun, and fired. He killed a police officer, who was not in uniform and Maye had no way of knowing it was the police, since it was the sound of the raid that woke him. But hey, fuck him, he should get the needle. Did I mention that he was innocent of any crime besides shooting an intruder who happened to be a cop?
How about Ryan Frederick? Police, in a similar raid, busted into his house, which had been burgled only a week earlier, in the middle of the night and he fired one shot in self-defense, killing an officer. He's facing life in prison.
Kathryn Johnston? A woman in her 90s who fired an antique gun exactly once at police serving a "no-knock" warrant on her apartment. You'll be happy to know that while she didn't hit any cops, she was killed in a hail of gunfire, and then the cops planted weed in her apartment to make the bust look justified. Interestingly, a few cops were injured in that raid, but it was from "friendly fire".
I really hope that this post doesn't come across as nothing but cop-hating, because like soldier I do admire the ones who do their job without having that gung-ho killer mentality. I also would think everyone would like to know all the facts of this tragedy before demanding the death penalty. I also hope I'm not crossing any lines of being banned or anything.
by jfiling » Wed Jul 16, 2008 9:16 pm
Peeker643 wrote:This sounds EXACTLY like the examples you listed there:
http://www.myfoxcleveland.com/myfox/pag ... geId=1.1.1
So tell me sir, what could possibly have transpired in the two minutes that led a guy with one cuff on his wrist to shoot the cop in the head 4 times? Two minutes between the time the cop ran the tags and the 'popping sounds' were heard. What scenario can you possibly create that's gonna make this one justifiable?
People have found human thumbs in Coke cans. You still drink soda or did that rare happening slant you away from all carbonated beverages. I saw a mice found in a can of corn. You still eat canned and packaged food? And can you list the millions of raids and arrests that were justified and that were properly executed that removed guns, drugs and assholes off the streets please?
Only the fucking piece of shit, limp dick assholes that kill cops get your benefit of the doubt?
Two uncles of mine did that work for years. Working domestic calls, SWAT, going into places most people don't have the balls to go. Save your bleeding heart bullshit and ghost stories for someone fucked up enough to listen to 'em.
Trying not to be personal J because for the most part I respect your shit, but that bias you have for cops touches a real big nerve. Not to mention the cocksucker and his cop killing client will be the only ones able to spin some fucking yarn about racial slurs, inappropriate conduct toward the dude's chick or whatever other crap they can come up with to try and save his stupid ass.
Your dime to my dollar that's coming.
How 'bout leaving it at 'due process' next time.
by peeker643 » Wed Jul 16, 2008 9:34 pm
Cool, you didn't make it personal
by jfiling » Wed Jul 16, 2008 9:38 pm
Peeker643 wrote:jfiling wrote:Cool, you didn't make it personal
You're correct dude. That ain't right. I changed my post. It ain't just you and that was out of line. But the sentiment stands.
by 4thQtrGlory » Wed Jul 16, 2008 10:35 pm

by jack_tors » Wed Jul 16, 2008 10:47 pm
jfiling wrote:I'm not going to respond to the personal attacks, but this one really gets me, because there is an innocent man sitting in prison for life due to this exact scenario. Cory Maye was sleeping in his home with his daughter when the cops raided his home. It was the wrong home, by the way. Fearing for his daughter's life, he shielded her with his body, grabbed his gun, and fired. He killed a police officer, who was not in uniform and Maye had no way of knowing it was the police, since it was the sound of the raid that woke him. But hey, fuck him, he should get the needle. Did I mention that he was innocent of any crime besides shooting an intruder who happened to be a cop?
How about Ryan Frederick? Police, in a similar raid, busted into his house, which had been burgled only a week earlier, in the middle of the night and he fired one shot in self-defense, killing an officer. He's facing life in prison.
Kathryn Johnston? A woman in her 90s who fired an antique gun exactly once at police serving a "no-knock" warrant on her apartment. You'll be happy to know that while she didn't hit any cops, she was killed in a hail of gunfire, and then the cops planted weed in her apartment to make the bust look justified. Interestingly, a few cops were injured in that raid, but it was from "friendly fire".
I really hope that this post doesn't come across as nothing but cop-hating, because like soldier I do admire the ones who do their job without having that gung-ho killer mentality. I also would think everyone would like to know all the facts of this tragedy before demanding the death penalty. I also hope I'm not crossing any lines of being banned or anything.
by jfiling » Wed Jul 16, 2008 11:08 pm
jack_tors wrote:All valid points, no doubt. My guess would be everyone on this board agrees there are a few cops out on the street that are bad or down right shady. Also, sure incidents like the ones you pointed out happen in this messed up world. Although, I think we can can agree that the good vastly outweighs the bad.
My point is this, my guess is when this case is resolved, we will find this suspect was drunk and irrationally reacted to being pulled over. This cop calls for backup from Reminderville and is shot within 30 seconds. There is no rationale, no conspiracy here, no track record of bad conduct by this officer or department that would lead any rational person to deduce that this kid is just a cold blooded killer. This suspect had brushes with the law before and in the matter of minutes a cop is dead without even pulling a weapon. I have absolutely no problem saying this punk deserves the chair. I had no issues with saying it last night, no issues today, and will bet the statement will hold true once the case is closed.
However, this is America and one of the great things is we have the ability to discuss these issues as free men and women. I don't agree with your take on the issue but you have the right to your opinion.
by peeker643 » Wed Jul 16, 2008 11:20 pm
jfiling wrote:jack_tors wrote:All valid points, no doubt. My guess would be everyone on this board agrees there are a few cops out on the street that are bad or down right shady. Also, sure incidents like the ones you pointed out happen in this messed up world. Although, I think we can can agree that the good vastly outweighs the bad.
My point is this, my guess is when this case is resolved, we will find this suspect was drunk and irrationally reacted to being pulled over. This cop calls for backup from Reminderville and is shot within 30 seconds. There is no rationale, no conspiracy here, no track record of bad conduct by this officer or department that would lead any rational person to deduce that this kid is just a cold blooded killer. This suspect had brushes with the law before and in the matter of minutes a cop is dead without even pulling a weapon. I have absolutely no problem saying this punk deserves the chair. I had no issues with saying it last night, no issues today, and will bet the statement will hold true once the case is closed.
However, this is America and one of the great things is we have the ability to discuss these issues as free men and women. I don't agree with your take on the issue but you have the right to your opinion.
You may be surprised, but I agree with you. I really hope that this is a case of a guy losing his mind and deciding that shooting a cop seemed like a good idea. This dead policeman, who by all accounts has done his job honorably, didn't deserve to die. Even if he did something to allow for a self-defense claim to be considered, he did not deserve to die. I do not want to be called out on that issue. And I have no reason to believe that this was a bad cop. I have followed these types of cases, as you've seen, and there must be some reason for a defense lawyer, who is an officer of the court and is sworn to not only give the best defense he can to his client, but tell the truth, to state that it was self-defense.
Honestly, if the lawyer is lying I emotionally want him to get the same punishment as the shooter. I'm willing to let the facts play out.
by jfiling » Wed Jul 16, 2008 11:29 pm
Peeker643 wrote:I'll end my time in this thread by just saying I've met and dealt with far more dishonest and unscrupulous attorneys than police officers in my time.
Like I said before, with the dog remaining in the car and his gun remaining in the holster, I can see absolutely no 'self-defense' justification for shooting anyone, much less a police officer, 4 times in the head. Add in that this all went down in just two minutes and it's just outside the scope of my imagination. Doesn't mean I'm right, but that's a serious stretch for me.
The officer's body was next to the cruiser according to the dispatch call. Sure seems to me like a plausible scenario being the guy got out of the car as the officer finished on the tag run and ambushed the poor bastard/or got involved in some type of altercation that resulted in the officer being able to get one cuff on the prick. All speculation. But with a concealed carry and a loaded weapon in the car the common procedure is to roll down your window and rest your hands on the window ledge the entire time.
by Greener » Thu Jul 17, 2008 9:34 am
by WarAdmiral » Thu Jul 17, 2008 10:36 am

by skatingtripods » Thu Jul 17, 2008 6:23 pm
jfiling wrote:This fucking scumbag should rot. I don't give a shit if he has a criminal record or not. HE KILLED A POLICE OFFICER. He could be the nicest guy in the world, would do anything for anybody, but if you kill a cop, fuck you.
I'm not going to respond to the personal attacks, but this one really gets me
by jfiling » Thu Jul 17, 2008 7:56 pm
Skating Tripods wrote:jfiling wrote:This fucking scumbag should rot. I don't give a shit if he has a criminal record or not. HE KILLED A POLICE OFFICER. He could be the nicest guy in the world, would do anything for anybody, but if you kill a cop, fuck you.
I'm not going to respond to the personal attacks, but this one really gets me
Do tell me with your infinite wisdom where there was a personal attack. I merely mentioned that your entire argument is bullshit and completely unfounded, being that the gun was holstered and the dog was in the backseat. I see absolutely no signs of aggressiveness from the cop. And if there were any signs of a struggle on this fuckstick, that would be out in the media already.
by jfiling » Thu Jul 17, 2008 10:09 pm
WarAdmiral wrote:Around three years ago, I was driving to work on a Sunday afternoon. I looked up in the rear view mirror and seen the blue lights. I pulled over, trying to figure out why I was being pulled over. I put both hands on the wheel and waited for the officer to ask me to roll the window down and so forth. To my surprise, he is screaming at me, and telling me to put both hands out the window. I almost crapped my pants, and complied. He had his hand on his gun, and I will never forget that feeling. I followed every order like a it could be my last day on earth.
Long story shortened, some guy had busted his wife up and left the scene about the same time I am driving down ole 14. The suspect was the same race, and driving the same color and model of truck, I was driving. After he ran my drivers license, he relaxed and apologized for scaring the shit out of me. He than explained why he did what he did. I told him to go get that son of a bitch. I hope it wasn't the same officer that was downed.
This guy deserves due process. No less, no more.
by Ziner » Thu Jul 17, 2008 11:53 pm
jfiling wrote:WarAdmiral wrote:Around three years ago, I was driving to work on a Sunday afternoon. I looked up in the rear view mirror and seen the blue lights. I pulled over, trying to figure out why I was being pulled over. I put both hands on the wheel and waited for the officer to ask me to roll the window down and so forth. To my surprise, he is screaming at me, and telling me to put both hands out the window. I almost crapped my pants, and complied. He had his hand on his gun, and I will never forget that feeling. I followed every order like a it could be my last day on earth.
Long story shortened, some guy had busted his wife up and left the scene about the same time I am driving down ole 14. The suspect was the same race, and driving the same color and model of truck, I was driving. After he ran my drivers license, he relaxed and apologized for scaring the shit out of me. He than explained why he did what he did. I told him to go get that son of a bitch. I hope it wasn't the same officer that was downed.
This guy deserves due process. No less, no more.
Wow. I give you a lot of credit for keeping your cool and understanding. I would have dealt with that way differently, and if I had the power the cop would no longer have his badge. Emotions should not play into how cops conduct reasonable stops. Your stop was reasonable, but the way this guy handled it was out of line. But, like I said, I'm glad that you were able to deal with it in the manner in which you did.
by jfiling » Fri Jul 18, 2008 12:18 am
Ziner wrote:jfiling wrote:WarAdmiral wrote:Around three years ago, I was driving to work on a Sunday afternoon. I looked up in the rear view mirror and seen the blue lights. I pulled over, trying to figure out why I was being pulled over. I put both hands on the wheel and waited for the officer to ask me to roll the window down and so forth. To my surprise, he is screaming at me, and telling me to put both hands out the window. I almost crapped my pants, and complied. He had his hand on his gun, and I will never forget that feeling. I followed every order like a it could be my last day on earth.
Long story shortened, some guy had busted his wife up and left the scene about the same time I am driving down ole 14. The suspect was the same race, and driving the same color and model of truck, I was driving. After he ran my drivers license, he relaxed and apologized for scaring the shit out of me. He than explained why he did what he did. I told him to go get that son of a bitch. I hope it wasn't the same officer that was downed.
This guy deserves due process. No less, no more.
Wow. I give you a lot of credit for keeping your cool and understanding. I would have dealt with that way differently, and if I had the power the cop would no longer have his badge. Emotions should not play into how cops conduct reasonable stops. Your stop was reasonable, but the way this guy handled it was out of line. But, like I said, I'm glad that you were able to deal with it in the manner in which you did.
See that is where you are 1000% wrong. The cop handle it in the exact way he should have been. He cant be wrong one time. That guy he was after already committed a violent crime. He didnt pull over a 90 year old lady in a wrong colored Buick. He had every reason to believe that the driver was this guy. If he goes up there non chalantly and the guy pulls a gun his life is over, much like the guy from Twinsburg. If the guy from Twinsburg had his gun pulled the entire time and made him and his girlfriend keep their hands where he could have seen them and been more aggressive he might be alive today. But it is people like you who try to erode the power of police officers because you want them to be right everytime instead of erroring on the side of caution. My dad who is a police officer of 28 years once something that made me feel a bit more confident in him being on the streets. Think about this. "It is better to be on trial in front 12 then carried by 6".
by peeker643 » Fri Jul 18, 2008 12:30 am
jfiling wrote:I understand. There is a philosophical disagreement here that is hard to overcome. I believe the police, since they are acting under the cover of government authority, must be in the right. Expecting anything less leads to abuse of power.
Let's take this specific case. The officer believed he MIGHT have the alleged wifebeater, and thought he might be a danger. You pull the guy over, and call and wait for backup, if you are concerned that he could be a threat to your life. Police cars have a P.A. system, and the cop could easily tell the suspect to wait in his car until backup arrived. By the way, in the meantime the cop could actually do the work of running the license plate and easily figuring out that this wasn't the suspect at all.
by Ziner » Fri Jul 18, 2008 12:44 am
jfiling wrote:
Let's take this specific case. The officer believed he MIGHT have the alleged wifebeater
by jfiling » Fri Jul 18, 2008 12:44 am
Peeker643 wrote:jfiling wrote:I understand. There is a philosophical disagreement here that is hard to overcome. I believe the police, since they are acting under the cover of government authority, must be in the right. Expecting anything less leads to abuse of power.
Let's take this specific case. The officer believed he MIGHT have the alleged wifebeater, and thought he might be a danger. You pull the guy over, and call and wait for backup, if you are concerned that he could be a threat to your life. Police cars have a P.A. system, and the cop could easily tell the suspect to wait in his car until backup arrived. By the way, in the meantime the cop could actually do the work of running the license plate and easily figuring out that this wasn't the suspect at all.
Tough to do consistently when most departments are stretched paper thin as it is. If it were that easy they'd all have a partner.
Yes, it would help matters like the T'Burg killing, but I'm not sure it's logistically feasible.
by jfiling » Fri Jul 18, 2008 12:48 am
Ziner wrote:jfiling wrote:
Let's take this specific case. The officer believed he MIGHT have the alleged wifebeater
The officer had reasonable suspicion to think he is the alleged wife beater. Under your scenario he sits there waits around for back up while the real wife beater gets farther away.
by Dozen » Fri Jul 18, 2008 1:34 am
jfiling wrote:Ziner wrote:jfiling wrote:
Let's take this specific case. The officer believed he MIGHT have the alleged wifebeater
The officer had reasonable suspicion to think he is the alleged wife beater. Under your scenario he sits there waits around for back up while the real wife beater gets farther away.
Huh? Under my scenario the cop pulls the guy over, runs his plates, and lets him on his way. He doesn't terrorize an innocent person. I really don't understand how that can be so complicated.
by jfiling » Fri Jul 18, 2008 2:03 am
Dozen wrote:jfiling wrote:Ziner wrote:jfiling wrote:
Let's take this specific case. The officer believed he MIGHT have the alleged wifebeater
The officer had reasonable suspicion to think he is the alleged wife beater. Under your scenario he sits there waits around for back up while the real wife beater gets farther away.
Huh? Under my scenario the cop pulls the guy over, runs his plates, and lets him on his way. He doesn't terrorize an innocent person. I really don't understand how that can be so complicated.
Jfiling, Hindsite is always 20/20. But another way to look at is by eliminating this subject may have helped them react quicker to the other guy. Under your scenerio the wife beata would have more time to get away while the cop sat and waited for back up on the wrong suspect. I'm sure it's not an easy decision to make but neither you nor I can even to pretend to know whats it like.
by Ziner » Fri Jul 18, 2008 11:30 am
jfiling wrote:Dozen wrote:jfiling wrote:Ziner wrote:jfiling wrote:
Let's take this specific case. The officer believed he MIGHT have the alleged wifebeater
The officer had reasonable suspicion to think he is the alleged wife beater. Under your scenario he sits there waits around for back up while the real wife beater gets farther away.
Huh? Under my scenario the cop pulls the guy over, runs his plates, and lets him on his way. He doesn't terrorize an innocent person. I really don't understand how that can be so complicated.
Jfiling, Hindsite is always 20/20. But another way to look at is by eliminating this subject may have helped them react quicker to the other guy. Under your scenerio the wife beata would have more time to get away while the cop sat and waited for back up on the wrong suspect. I'm sure it's not an easy decision to make but neither you nor I can even to pretend to know whats it like.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest
