Indians Starting Rotation Career Comps

[swerb]

Saw jfiling mention Westbrook's career comps in the Westbrook/Nagy thread, thought it would be interesting to see the career profile similarities on the other members of the rotation (sans Sowers, not enough history) ...

C.C. Sabathia

10 most similar pitchers through age 25

Tony Cloninger (962)
Dan Petry (939)
Ken Holtzman (939)
Greg Maddux (934)
Steve Avery (933)
Jerry Reuss (930)
Richard Dotson (928)
Mike Witt (927)
Mark Buehrle (924)
Mark Gubicza (923)

Jake Westbrook

10 most similar pitchers through age 28

Carl Pavano (977)
Oil Can Boyd (975)
Bill Wegman (971)
Johnny Marcum (969)
Sloppy Thurston (968)
Adam Eaton (967)
Rich Gale (967)
Aaron Sele (967)
Charles Nagy (965)
Jason Schmidt (964)

Cliff Lee

10 most similar pitchers through age 27

Pete Schourek (966)
Jarrod Washburn (958)
Bartolo Colon (957)
Darren Oliver (956)
Tom Browning (954)
Earl Whitehill (952)
Fred Klobedanz (951)
Bob Ojeda (950)
Aaron Sele (950)
Adam Eaton (949)

Paul Byrd

10 most similar pitchers through age 35

Cal Eldred (954)
Woody Williams (951)
Mark Gardner (936)
Mike Bielecki (933)
Bob Muncrief (932)
Dennis Rasmussen (930)
Nels Potter (928)
Armando Reynoso (928)
Danny Cox (927)
Bill Swift (926)