by papacass » Fri Dec 25, 2009 2:46 pm
Shaq isn't a good fit for the Cavs. But to the "Get rid of Shaq NOW" camp, I only ask:
Who guards Dwight Howard in a playoff series? Because if the Cavs don't at least neutralize Howard somewhat, it's the '09 ECF all over again. And right now it looks like the Cavs are steamrolling toward a second-round matchup with the Disneys.
Until someone can make a convincing argument as to why the Cavs are better off playing the Magic without Shaq available to guard Dewey, I'm not going to believe the Cavs are better off without Shaq. Even if he fits the offense like alfredo sauce fits an ice cream sundae.
I still wholeheartedly believe that people who are bellyaching about the shortcomings of playing with Shaq during the regular season are missing the bigger picture. It's not about how smooth the offense looks in the middle of winter. It's about winning exhausting, Greco-Roman wrestling, slobberknocker playoff series in late May and June. I really don't care if the offense looks pretty in late December. I care about winning filthy, nasty, ugly, bloody Pistons-Celtics circa 1988 seven-games series in the spring. I don't care about the points Shaq scores. I really don't even care about his hook shot dropping. I care about him banging rib cages with Dewey, Gasol, Bynum, Horford, Sheed, Perkins and whoever else, making them work for every last point. That's how you win titles.
Now, you can argue until purple in the face about whether Shaq can, in fact, still do that effectively. But that's why he's here, and at this point, I don't see a better available alternative for at least wearing down other teams with dominant big men.
Just remember: The offense will look worse in the later rounds of the playoffs regardless of who the Cavs run out there. It's a byproduct of playing elite defensive teams. Playoff basketball is slow and deliberate. You don't get style points. You get wins and losses.