CP wrote:fundamentals wrote:So let me get this straight, the Celtics are ridiculed for trying to better their team by adding Moore and Marbury and the Cavaliers are being lauded for adding Joe Smith? Home town spin.

To be fair, it's not like the Cavaliers are adding Joe Smith off the scrap heap. Marbury hasn't played in over a year; the equivalent to bringing him in would have been bringing in Jason Williams if the league would have reinstated him from retirement.
Also, Smith was on the team last year and was traded because he was an expiring deal that fit and was needed to bring in Mo Williams. The team acknowledged that Lorenzen Wright was more of a warm body replacement for Smith than anything else.
The Mikki Moore move wouldn't have seemed so desperate without the Marbury addition in conjunction and if the Celtics hadn't already made it known that Joe Smith was their first choice.
On his ESPN power rankings this week, Marc Stein asked if the Celtics adding Moore and Marbury this year is really all that different from adding Sam Cassell and P.J. Brown last year. He was trying to discredit the whole idea that the C's were/are desperate for bench help.
My response: It's very different. Brown was a three-time all-defensive first teamer and starter for a contending Heat team in his prime. Moore is a journeyman whose career highlights include a stint as the best big man on the Nets roster during their epic run to the second round of the '07 playoffs, where the Cavs neatly dispatched them in six games.
Cassell is a born-and-bred floor general who won two titles with the Rockets and helped fashion a rare season of respectability for the Clippers a couple of years ago. Marbury is a volume shooter who historically hasn't been able to contribute anything positive without massive amounts of touches.
As an addition, Joe Smith is much closer to Brown than Moore. He had productive stints with the Warriors and Wolves before beginning the journeyman phase of his career. Even at this point in his career, he has more skills than Moore could ever hope to accumulate.
I think Danny Ainge panicked a bit and went with the quickest fixes he could find, instead of holding his cards and waiting to see what developed between the trade deadline and March 1. Hopefully in landing Smith, the Cavs are going to reap the benefits of Ainge's haste. Because I have no doubt that if the Celtics would have come knocking, Smith would have answered.