Cleveland Matt wrote:bac5665 wrote:Let's make this easy.
To win the Super Bowl, you need a Hall of Fame QB. Period. Trent Dilfer doesn't win for the Ravens anymore. The rules have changed to much.
Is Tebow a Hall of Fame QB? Answer that question and you have the answer.
Is Eli Mannings a HOF QB and I would debate that Rapeburgh is a HOF QB. You need more then one player to win a good QB helps but you need a whole team around them as well.
I'm sure that Rapelesburger is in. He's won two Superbowls and been in a 3rd. And, unfortunately, I really do think that he'll be in more. He's a lock for the Hall.
Manning, maybe, maybe not. But he's certainly in the discussion. The 07 SB was pretty special. But remember, it took a stupidly unbelievable catch to win that game, and so if Manning slips into the list as a lucky guy who was also as hot as any QB ever, then I don't think that he disproves the overall point.