Final Assesment: In Relative Terms

[mistero]

My final thoughts on who is what...

1. Jemarcuss Russell:
20% John Elway
60% Steve McNair
10% Jared Lorenzen
10% Spergyn Wynn

2. Brady Quinn :
20% Joe Montana
40% Chad Pennington
20% Troy Aikman
20% Ty Detmer

3. Adrian Peterson:
30% Eddie George
30% Eric Dickerson
20% Jim Brown
20% Lee Suggs

4. Joe Thomas:
50% Tra Thomas
30% Roman Oben
20% Robert Gallery

5. Calvin Johnson:
40% Terrell Ownes
40% Chad Johnson
10% Jerry Rice
10% Marvin Harrison


The five guys I would love to get out of this draft are Amobi Okoye, Lamar Woodley, Aaron Sears, Justin Blalock and Michael Bush.

See ya saturday!

[swerb]

Nicely done Mistero.

Im done analyzing and predicting. Its time to saddle up and see what happens.

Looking forward to Saturday man ... four straight years of watching the draft together my friend.

Browns could do alot worse than Okoye and Sears. I like both of those guys as well.

[Guest]

From that analysis, I analyze that you love Calvin Johnson, and have no great passion for Joe Thomas.

[mistero]

4 years? Feels like just yesterday....




From that analysis, I analyze that you love Calvin Johnson, and have no great passion for Joe Thomas.

Thomas is a nice player but most drafts I think you'd find him in the twenties of the 1st round or early second. Johnson is the perfect WR. I just loathe drafting WR in round one. So, I think he's great but would be a real waste of value for the 3rd pick (see Edwards,Braylon).

[pod2dawg]

nice work mistero, I too would probably take the guys slotted from 15 down, less risk better value.....makes the misses less painful I guess.

[Wolfy]

40% Terell and Chad 10% Rice and Marvin...That's the best WR I have ever heard of, the only thing missing is his red cape.

[Kuiper]

CJ is getting way too much love and respect. All draft picks have some risk and you're effectively claiming that Johnson is a no risk pick in terms of performance. There is at least a 10% risk that every top wide receiver pick becomes David Terrell. If anything, your view that there is an 80% chance he will become Owens or Johnson is way off because it implies that there is a near certainty that he will develop an attitude problem. Everything I've read suggests that is the one thing he doesn't have a risk of developing. Much more likely he develops the case of the dropsies after getting smashed in the mouth a couple of times in the pros than he will become an imature jerk for the first time.

[Guest]

CJ deserves the respect he is getting
Time will tell.

[pup]

CJ is as close to a can't miss as there is in any draft. Yes, there is a risk with anyone, a chance that the good life gets to his head, maybe bigger corners give him a problem.

If you are projecting anyone there should be a buffer for being a bust, but overall I would agree with most of Mistero's percentages (other than Mr. Thomas).