Moderators: peeker643, jb, swerb, pup
by Pufferbelly » Mon Jan 26, 2009 10:32 pm
by Ziner » Mon Jan 26, 2009 10:45 pm
Pufferbelly wrote:
Anderson- 3rd and 7th rounder
Edwards- 2nd rounder
Winslow- 2nd rounder
by mistero » Mon Jan 26, 2009 10:49 pm
by Crash Davis » Tue Jan 27, 2009 12:11 am
Ziner wrote:Pufferbelly wrote:
Anderson- 3rd and 7th rounder
Edwards- 2nd rounder
Winslow- 2nd rounder
Anderson - not a chance. He MAY be able to be traded for a 4th or 5th rounder... maybe. Probably a 6th if at all. He isnt a hot commodity, thanks for blowing that one Phil
Edwards - please see other threads. BE is not going anywhere. He is certainly not going anywhere for a 2nd. At minimum we will need a 1st just to replace him. What is the point of trading him for a 2nd. You are not going to be able to replace him for a 2nd, thus you weaken the team.
Winslow - I would not trade him for at least a 2nd and 5th. The Giants got that out of the Saints so I think you are undervaluing him. I would be willing to deal him but I would prefer a late first or at minimum a mid 2nd rounder and 5th rounder (which is more likely than a 1st obviously). I keep seeing Buffalo in mocks picking up Brandon Pettigrew. Perhaps we could get their 2nd and 4th or so for Winslow, then instead they would have a sure thing and we could then use Heiden and Rucker.
by Ziner » Tue Jan 27, 2009 12:23 am
Crash Davis wrote:Ziner wrote:Pufferbelly wrote:
Anderson- 3rd and 7th rounder
Edwards- 2nd rounder
Winslow- 2nd rounder
Anderson - not a chance. He MAY be able to be traded for a 4th or 5th rounder... maybe. Probably a 6th if at all. He isnt a hot commodity, thanks for blowing that one Phil
Edwards - please see other threads. BE is not going anywhere. He is certainly not going anywhere for a 2nd. At minimum we will need a 1st just to replace him. What is the point of trading him for a 2nd. You are not going to be able to replace him for a 2nd, thus you weaken the team.
Winslow - I would not trade him for at least a 2nd and 5th. The Giants got that out of the Saints so I think you are undervaluing him. I would be willing to deal him but I would prefer a late first or at minimum a mid 2nd rounder and 5th rounder (which is more likely than a 1st obviously). I keep seeing Buffalo in mocks picking up Brandon Pettigrew. Perhaps we could get their 2nd and 4th or so for Winslow, then instead they would have a sure thing and we could then use Heiden and Rucker.
I hear ya Z but it looks like the Browns according to NFL Network's Adam Schefter think they can get a second rounder or at least won't part with DA unless they can obtain a 2nd rounder. I would be happy with a 3rd and extremely happy with a second.
"To get Anderson is going to cost at least a second-round pick, and maybe a first, and that's a steep price. Then again, Minnesota traded its 1 last year and that worked out pretty well, didn't it?"
http://chat.nfl.com/front/archived_chat/104
by 4thQtrGlory » Tue Jan 27, 2009 12:35 am

by Triple-S » Tue Jan 27, 2009 12:37 am
4thQtrGlory wrote:Heres how i see it....
DA- gone....no matter what, he is gone. Sure, Kokinis and Mangini are acting hard and hoping for a nice draft pick. Chances are, we dont get many nice offers and end up parting ways with him for a 2nd day pick. The main thing is getting rid of his contract and roster bonus. Also, there needs to be NO qb controversy, and there wont.
Braylon- as much as i hate him, we wont get jackshit in return for him. If any receiver gets dumped, itll be donte stallworth. Who would we put in his spot? Steptoe? Donte? Free Agent? no way
K2- I can go both ways on this. I think he is a playmaker and has great ability. BUt.......i know his knees are a ticking time bomb, he will never be 100%, wants a new contract to be the highest paid TE, and o ya...drew rosenhaus is his agent. If we could get a 2nd round draft pick (33-45), then id strongly consider.
Swerb wrote:Go start a blog if you want to tell the world your incomprehendible ramblings.
Cerebral_DownTime wrote:I have a big arm and can throw the ball pretty damn far...... maybe even over those moutains. The Browns should sign me, i'll let you all in locker room to drink beer. Then we can all go out the parking lot to watch me do motorcycle stunts.

by peeker643 » Tue Jan 27, 2009 12:45 am
Triple-S wrote:4thQtrGlory wrote:Heres how i see it....
DA- gone....no matter what, he is gone. Sure, Kokinis and Mangini are acting hard and hoping for a nice draft pick. Chances are, we dont get many nice offers and end up parting ways with him for a 2nd day pick. The main thing is getting rid of his contract and roster bonus. Also, there needs to be NO qb controversy, and there wont.
Braylon- as much as i hate him, we wont get jackshit in return for him. If any receiver gets dumped, itll be donte stallworth. Who would we put in his spot? Steptoe? Donte? Free Agent? no way
K2- I can go both ways on this. I think he is a playmaker and has great ability. BUt.......i know his knees are a ticking time bomb, he will never be 100%, wants a new contract to be the highest paid TE, and o ya...drew rosenhaus is his agent. If we could get a 2nd round draft pick (33-45), then id strongly consider.
I can see some team offering us a 2-3rd..but maybe thats just me. He's young and some what of a vetaran, something in need for teams like Detroit and Minnesota.
by 4thQtrGlory » Tue Jan 27, 2009 12:48 am
Triple-S wrote:4thQtrGlory wrote:Heres how i see it....
DA- gone....no matter what, he is gone. Sure, Kokinis and Mangini are acting hard and hoping for a nice draft pick. Chances are, we dont get many nice offers and end up parting ways with him for a 2nd day pick. The main thing is getting rid of his contract and roster bonus. Also, there needs to be NO qb controversy, and there wont.
Braylon- as much as i hate him, we wont get jackshit in return for him. If any receiver gets dumped, itll be donte stallworth. Who would we put in his spot? Steptoe? Donte? Free Agent? no way
K2- I can go both ways on this. I think he is a playmaker and has great ability. BUt.......i know his knees are a ticking time bomb, he will never be 100%, wants a new contract to be the highest paid TE, and o ya...drew rosenhaus is his agent. If we could get a 2nd round draft pick (33-45), then id strongly consider.
I can see some team offering us a 2-3rd..but maybe thats just me. He's young and some what of a vetaran, something in need for teams like Detroit and Minnesota.

by Ziner » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:08 am
Triple-S wrote:4thQtrGlory wrote:Heres how i see it....
DA- gone....no matter what, he is gone. Sure, Kokinis and Mangini are acting hard and hoping for a nice draft pick. Chances are, we dont get many nice offers and end up parting ways with him for a 2nd day pick. The main thing is getting rid of his contract and roster bonus. Also, there needs to be NO qb controversy, and there wont.
Braylon- as much as i hate him, we wont get jackshit in return for him. If any receiver gets dumped, itll be donte stallworth. Who would we put in his spot? Steptoe? Donte? Free Agent? no way
K2- I can go both ways on this. I think he is a playmaker and has great ability. BUt.......i know his knees are a ticking time bomb, he will never be 100%, wants a new contract to be the highest paid TE, and o ya...drew rosenhaus is his agent. If we could get a 2nd round draft pick (33-45), then id strongly consider.
I can see some team offering us a 2-3rd..but maybe thats just me. He's young and some what of a vetaran, something in need for teams like Detroit and Minnesota.
by hermanfontenot » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:08 am

by 4thQtrGlory » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:13 am
HermanFontenot wrote:I think we can get a first-day pick for DA. Some GM is going to look at that size, that arm, and the starting experience and say, This guy has proven he can start and win in this league. He has some deficiencies, but he was also stuck in an awful situation in Cleveland; the fans were all over him from the start, his receivers couldn't catch a cold running barefoot through Barrow in January, there were injuries on the offensive line, etc etc... it wouldn't surprise me at all to see someone offer up a 2nd or 3rd.

by Ziner » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:15 am
4thQtrGlory wrote:HermanFontenot wrote:I think we can get a first-day pick for DA. Some GM is going to look at that size, that arm, and the starting experience and say, This guy has proven he can start and win in this league. He has some deficiencies, but he was also stuck in an awful situation in Cleveland; the fans were all over him from the start, his receivers couldn't catch a cold running barefoot through Barrow in January, there were injuries on the offensive line, etc etc... it wouldn't surprise me at all to see someone offer up a 2nd or 3rd.
I hope you guys are right, i hope im wrong!
by ilasch » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:30 am
Ziner wrote:4thQtrGlory wrote:HermanFontenot wrote:I think we can get a first-day pick for DA. Some GM is going to look at that size, that arm, and the starting experience and say, This guy has proven he can start and win in this league. He has some deficiencies, but he was also stuck in an awful situation in Cleveland; the fans were all over him from the start, his receivers couldn't catch a cold running barefoot through Barrow in January, there were injuries on the offensive line, etc etc... it wouldn't surprise me at all to see someone offer up a 2nd or 3rd.
I hope you guys are right, i hope im wrong!
Me too, I will take a 2nd or 3rd, but I am expecting lower than a 4th to being released outright.
by Ziner » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:39 am
ilasch wrote:Ziner wrote:4thQtrGlory wrote:HermanFontenot wrote:I think we can get a first-day pick for DA. Some GM is going to look at that size, that arm, and the starting experience and say, This guy has proven he can start and win in this league. He has some deficiencies, but he was also stuck in an awful situation in Cleveland; the fans were all over him from the start, his receivers couldn't catch a cold running barefoot through Barrow in January, there were injuries on the offensive line, etc etc... it wouldn't surprise me at all to see someone offer up a 2nd or 3rd.
I hope you guys are right, i hope im wrong!
Me too, I will take a 2nd or 3rd, but I am expecting lower than a 4th to being released outright.
At the time he was traded, Matt Schaub had the following stats in actual NFL games:
84 completions
161 attempts
52.2% complete
1,033 yards
6.42 yards per attempt
6 TDs
6 INTs
72.30 qb rating
Derek Anderson, so far in his career, has the following stats:
506 completions
927 attempts
54.6% complete
6,195 yards
6.68 yards per attempt
9 TDs
8 INTs
75.1 qb rating
The Falcons received two 2nd round draft picks and swapped places in the first round. Though they only moved up two spots, from #10 to #8, that's the equivalent of a 4th-round pick by the draft value chart most teams use. (http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/draft06/n ... id=2410670)
Keeping in mind that Anderson also has one more Pro Bowl on his resume than Matt Schaub had, doesn't it seem possible that maybe someone out there will give up a 2nd rounder for him?
by jb » Tue Jan 27, 2009 10:48 am
by jb » Tue Jan 27, 2009 10:50 am
HermanFontenot wrote:I think we can get a first-day pick for DA. Some GM is going to look at that size, that arm, and the starting experience and say, This guy has proven he can start and win in this league. He has some deficiencies, but he was also stuck in an awful situation in Cleveland; the fans were all over him from the start, his receivers couldn't catch a cold running barefoot through Barrow in January, there were injuries on the offensive line, etc etc... it wouldn't surprise me at all to see someone offer up a 2nd or 3rd.
by noles1 » Tue Jan 27, 2009 10:55 am

by jameseboy » Tue Jan 27, 2009 11:32 am
by oberle » Tue Jan 27, 2009 11:55 am
JB wrote:That's what they all say at the start. It's kinda like a Jurassic Park sequel.
Firs there's the "build thru the draft", then there's two six win seasons and the drum beats start. The kids they hand jobs to to validate their genius aren't ready or aren't alll that good and then , whoosh, here come the FA's.
by Madre Hill, Superstar » Tue Jan 27, 2009 12:23 pm

by Hydra Melee » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:09 pm
jameseboy wrote:Trading Edwards and Winslow would be addition by subtraction. If you traded em for a bag of balls you would upgrade the team. I dont have any idea what you might get for them but they should move them for whatever the best deal might be and not look back. Just take the money you would have paid them and use it on free agents.
by OrangeElf » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:50 pm
Hydra Melee wrote:jameseboy wrote:Trading Edwards and Winslow would be addition by subtraction. If you traded em for a bag of balls you would upgrade the team. I dont have any idea what you might get for them but they should move them for whatever the best deal might be and not look back. Just take the money you would have paid them and use it on free agents.
That better be one talented bag of balls.
We do NOT have enough in the receiving corps to "add by subtracting".
by pod2dawg » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:54 pm

by OrangeElf » Tue Jan 27, 2009 1:59 pm
pod2dawg wrote:I'm pretty much convinced I could GM or coach the Browns..well better than the last decade's results anyway. I'm going to immediately apply for a non-paying ball-boy job and start the journey.
by BruceK » Tue Jan 27, 2009 2:39 pm

by Ziner » Tue Jan 27, 2009 2:40 pm
BruceK wrote:Re: possible market for DA
Has Chudzinkski landed a job yet? That could play a part in any interest for DA
by bw » Tue Jan 27, 2009 2:50 pm
JB wrote:HermanFontenot wrote:I think we can get a first-day pick for DA. Some GM is going to look at that size, that arm, and the starting experience and say, This guy has proven he can start and win in this league. He has some deficiencies, but he was also stuck in an awful situation in Cleveland; the fans were all over him from the start, his receivers couldn't catch a cold running barefoot through Barrow in January, there were injuries on the offensive line, etc etc... it wouldn't surprise me at all to see someone offer up a 2nd or 3rd.
The best thing we have going for us as far as DA's value is our piss poor reputation.
There have to be those who will blame the org and not the player or coach after all the f ups that have come out of Berea. Maybe this raises DA's value?
by Hydra Melee » Tue Jan 27, 2009 3:37 pm
DA didn't just suddenly forget how to play football.
by ProgRocker » Tue Jan 27, 2009 4:07 pm
), and it's turning into a weak draft for QBs, so I think there are possibilities.
by Yinzer Hater » Tue Jan 27, 2009 5:17 pm
ProgRocker wrote:I've been arguing for awhile that the Browns' best bet may be to package Anderson and Winslow, either to a dome team or a warm-weather team that would like to play a vertical game. Do that and I would hope they could get at least a 2/3/one more combo, or maybe a 1/4 if the first round pick is in the middle of the pack. DA is still a former Pro Bowler that a lot of NFL people think was mishandled by Romeo (), and it's turning into a weak draft for QBs, so I think there are possibilities.
Two teams I would call if I were ManKok would be Minnesota (a team with a history of giving picks away that thinks they're a breakout QB away from really contending) and Tampa Bay (a team that made one panic move by ditching Chucky specifically because he didn't do enough to build offense, and who probably are willing to gamble next year to get to one more Super Bowl).
by hornet84 » Tue Jan 27, 2009 5:39 pm
by Crash Davis » Tue Jan 27, 2009 6:01 pm
hornet84 wrote:Don't you have to have draft choices for that ? Phil did not leave us with many choices in the upcoming draft.That would lead you to believe that the Browns will be willing to move some bodies to get some picks back. What do you guys think is the more likely scenario trading our #5 pick for multiple choices , moving players on the current roster, or both ?
by ProgRocker » Tue Jan 27, 2009 8:44 pm
Yinzer Hater wrote:ProgRocker wrote:I've been arguing for awhile that the Browns' best bet may be to package Anderson and Winslow, either to a dome team or a warm-weather team that would like to play a vertical game. Do that and I would hope they could get at least a 2/3/one more combo, or maybe a 1/4 if the first round pick is in the middle of the pack. DA is still a former Pro Bowler that a lot of NFL people think was mishandled by Romeo (), and it's turning into a weak draft for QBs, so I think there are possibilities.
Two teams I would call if I were ManKok would be Minnesota (a team with a history of giving picks away that thinks they're a breakout QB away from really contending) and Tampa Bay (a team that made one panic move by ditching Chucky specifically because he didn't do enough to build offense, and who probably are willing to gamble next year to get to one more Super Bowl).
First healthy offseason since he's been drafted and you want to send K2 packing? He's under contract for a few more years so if Braylon walks at the end of this year when his deal is up we'd be left with neither.
Besides sounds like he may be a big beneficiary of the new offense Daboll wants to run and perfect compliment to Quinn's style.
by ProgRocker » Tue Jan 27, 2009 8:45 pm
Crash Davis wrote:hornet84 wrote:Don't you have to have draft choices for that ? Phil did not leave us with many choices in the upcoming draft.That would lead you to believe that the Browns will be willing to move some bodies to get some picks back. What do you guys think is the more likely scenario trading our #5 pick for multiple choices , moving players on the current roster, or both ?
You get a 3rd and a 5th for DA then you have all but your 7th round back and call it a day. No one is going to give up any more than that for Mr. Anderson.
by mattvan1 » Wed Jan 28, 2009 12:29 am
ProgRocker wrote: Second, unlike Braylon KW wants a new contract and has taken action -- including, from most accounts, the whole controversy about the staph infection from last season -- in an effort to get that contract ... in other words, while Braylon has shot his mouth off KW took actions that directly subverted the organization, such as it is.
by e0y2e3 » Wed Jan 28, 2009 12:38 am
mattvan1 wrote:ProgRocker wrote: Second, unlike Braylon KW wants a new contract and has taken action -- including, from most accounts, the whole controversy about the staph infection from last season -- in an effort to get that contract ... in other words, while Braylon has shot his mouth off KW took actions that directly subverted the organization, such as it is.
And history gets revised yet again. Maybe Pat Mac is to blame.

by ProgRocker » Wed Jan 28, 2009 7:48 pm
e0y2e3 wrote:mattvan1 wrote:ProgRocker wrote: Second, unlike Braylon KW wants a new contract and has taken action -- including, from most accounts, the whole controversy about the staph infection from last season -- in an effort to get that contract ... in other words, while Braylon has shot his mouth off KW took actions that directly subverted the organization, such as it is.
And history gets revised yet again. Maybe Pat Mac is to blame.
Honestly, I have been trying to point out ProgDouche's refusal to accept factual history for years.
He always claims it is because I don't like his politics (which is just a completely moronic statement).
In reality the guy really needs to work on his reading comprehension and memory while staring deeply into a mirror. Things just come out completely distorted from reality 75+% of the time.

by jb » Wed Jan 28, 2009 7:59 pm
BruceK wrote:Re: possible market for DA
Has Chudzinkski landed a job yet? That could play a part in any interest for DA

by 4thQtrGlory » Wed Jan 28, 2009 8:05 pm
Ziner wrote:BruceK wrote:Re: possible market for DA
Has Chudzinkski landed a job yet? That could play a part in any interest for DA
Yeah in San Diego. Nice thought though


by jamesownsdet » Wed Jan 28, 2009 8:21 pm
Crash Davis wrote:hornet84 wrote:Don't you have to have draft choices for that ? Phil did not leave us with many choices in the upcoming draft.That would lead you to believe that the Browns will be willing to move some bodies to get some picks back. What do you guys think is the more likely scenario trading our #5 pick for multiple choices , moving players on the current roster, or both ?
You get a 3rd and a 5th for DA then you have all but your 7th round back and call it a day. No one is going to give up any more than that for Mr. Anderson.
by 4thQtrGlory » Wed Jan 28, 2009 9:01 pm
jamesownsdet wrote:Crash Davis wrote:hornet84 wrote:Don't you have to have draft choices for that ? Phil did not leave us with many choices in the upcoming draft.That would lead you to believe that the Browns will be willing to move some bodies to get some picks back. What do you guys think is the more likely scenario trading our #5 pick for multiple choices , moving players on the current roster, or both ?
You get a 3rd and a 5th for DA then you have all but your 7th round back and call it a day. No one is going to give up any more than that for Mr. Anderson.
Isn't it more likely a team will simply wait for the Browns to cut Anderson before they have to pay him that 5 million dollar roster bonus rather than trade anything for him?

Return to Cleveland Browns & The NFL
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests